Who do you think is the best mapper of all time?

Voting time! Hard decision.

There's been a lot of VERY good mappers but one total standout for me. Thats who I chose

Too impossible to choose just one mapper, I'm afraid.

Gary Ragland.

I am, obviously.

But it's hard to speak of 'the best mapper', I think it's better to speak in terms of your favourite mapper. And at the moment that's AreyeP. But so many of that list are so great. After working with Dean on Sonder and playing his maps I am definitely convinced he's one of the best. Ack can only make awesome maps it seems. BJ Rowan made Totengraeber, therefore is awesome. Arielus made The Golden Episodes, which is one of the first mods I played and instantly liked.

And I can probably name something for every mapper on that list. But if I have to name a favourite mapper it is definitely AreyeP for me.

BJ Rowan, Gary Ragland, it's hard to pick a side. I like ack's maps, but it seems it's all about the grey slime and the tricky passages, columns, etc... I'd like to see a plain, square-shaped running-around-the-bunker map... As tedious as it sounds.

But where is Jack Ryerson and Chris on that list?! Shame on you!!!

Not to mention Nathaniel Rudiak-Gould - "Temporary Insanity" No one can pull that off. Not to mention Maarten Pinxten. Spearmpixsod or whatever is probably the best Spear map set out there.

I chose "other" because at least 1/3 of the list is a tie for me.

Is Tenamk on that list? xd

Thomas wrote:

But where is Jack Ryerson and Chris on that list?! Shame on you!!!

Who is that?

Anyways, I am suprised to see Schabbs in 1st palce tied with ack! Interesting. I think I might know what you mean by "a running around the bunker level".

Wow a whole total 8 votes, this certainly isn't a very definitive result!