So this is basically, at the very least inspired by, a thread Chris started on the DHW, but I thought I'd post it here, in a slightly modified form (not as a poll and I'm also marking favorites). I'll print my list from DHW and a * indicates roughly the top third of what I've played:
1. Wolfen60
2. Wolf2Gam
3. Enigma's Nightmare
4. Enigma 2
5. Enigma 3
6. Death Maps for Wolf3D
7. nat_w3d (shareware episode later turned into Temporary Insanity)
8. 1st.zip for SoD
9. The Renovation
10. Armageddon
11. The Road to Neushwanstein
12. Assassinate Hitler*
13. Schabbs 2000*
14. ATAW3D*
15. Arielus' Wolfenstein 3D
16. Wolfenstein Umbrella Beginnings
17. Third Reich Episode 1: A Dark Secret
18. Acktung! 2: The Last Waltz*
19. Totenkopf SDL*
20. SoD Reloaded*
21. Deadly Sleep*
22. NovoWolf*
23. Endlosung
24. End of Destiny*
25. Chrono - Spear of Destiny levels
26. Castle Grom
27. Escape from Castle Holle
28. The Bitter End
29. W.O.L.F.
30. The Hunt for Von Hauer
31. Trilogy Revisited + Nocturnal Missions
32. Guns and Glory (2007)
33. Absence*
34. Team Aardwolf Mapset
35. Spear of Destiny Mappack
36. Spear Revisited
37. Archives Volume I*
38. Archives Volume II*
39. The False Spear (Dos)
40. Castle Assault*
41. Operation Hidden Secret
42. This Spear*
43. medEvil
44. Revivial of Memories*
45. Nazi Operation
46. Rising Evil
47. Operation Letzterschutz*
48. Project: Totengraeber*
49. Operation Heimzulhang
50. Alliance of Powers*
51. The Last Mission
52. Coming of the Storm*
53. Beyond Mutantstein SE (original)
54. Berlin Express
55. Countdown to Disaster
56. Chemical Warfare*
57. 15 Master Levels
58. Guns & Glory 0.5 The Story Retold*
59. Project Eisenritter*
60. Map of the Month June 2007
61. Map of the Month July 2007
62. Map of the Month August 2007
63. Map of the Month September 2007
64. Thomas' Wolfenstein 3D
65. Chemical Reaction
66. Ipank's Spear of Destiny*
67. Episode Four
68. SS
1. Wolfen60
2. Wolf2Gam
3. Enigma's Nightmare
4. Enigma 2
5. Enigma 3
6. Death Maps for Wolf3D
7. nat_w3d (shareware episode later turned into Temporary Insanity)
8. 1st.zip for SoD
9. The Renovation
10. Armageddon
11. The Road to Neushwanstein
12. Assassinate Hitler*
13. Schabbs 2000*
14. ATAW3D*
15. Arielus' Wolfenstein 3D
16. Wolfenstein Umbrella Beginnings
17. Third Reich Episode 1: A Dark Secret
18. Acktung! 2: The Last Waltz*
19. Totenkopf SDL*
20. SoD Reloaded*
21. Deadly Sleep*
22. NovoWolf*
23. Endlosung
24. End of Destiny*
25. Chrono - Spear of Destiny levels
26. Castle Grom
27. Escape from Castle Holle
28. The Bitter End
29. W.O.L.F.
30. The Hunt for Von Hauer
31. Trilogy Revisited + Nocturnal Missions
32. Guns and Glory (2007)
33. Absence*
34. Team Aardwolf Mapset
35. Spear of Destiny Mappack
36. Spear Revisited
37. Archives Volume I*
38. Archives Volume II*
39. The False Spear (Dos)
40. Castle Assault*
41. Operation Hidden Secret
42. This Spear*
43. medEvil
44. Revivial of Memories*
45. Nazi Operation
46. Rising Evil
47. Operation Letzterschutz*
48. Project: Totengraeber*
49. Operation Heimzulhang
50. Alliance of Powers*
51. The Last Mission
52. Coming of the Storm*
53. Beyond Mutantstein SE (original)
54. Berlin Express
55. Countdown to Disaster
56. Chemical Warfare*
57. 15 Master Levels
58. Guns & Glory 0.5 The Story Retold*
59. Project Eisenritter*
60. Map of the Month June 2007
61. Map of the Month July 2007
62. Map of the Month August 2007
63. Map of the Month September 2007
64. Thomas' Wolfenstein 3D
65. Chemical Reaction
66. Ipank's Spear of Destiny*
67. Episode Four
68. SS